THE CAIRD COMPASS
FALL 2026
In our view, much of what changed on bank balance sheets since our July issue comes back to one idea: money has a price again. It shows up in what duration costs a securities book, in what liquidity is worth against a loan book, and in how the market now treats any business model that needs new debt to keep running.
That idea runs through this issue: why commercial real estate concentration is a correlation problem before it is a credit problem, where borrowers go when they have a choice of lender, how a bank with a syndication desk can hold loans it did not originate, and why the market is asking harder questions of the companies financing the AI build. We hope you find it useful.
The Caird Team
FROM THE CAIRD TEAM
Why Regulators Measure CRE Concentration and Not C&I
Bank supervisors screen commercial real estate concentration against total risk-based capital. There is no comparable screen for commercial and industrial lending. The usual explanation is that CRE loses more. In our view, the charge-off record is closer than that: CRE peaked at 2.85% after 2008 against 2.57% for C&I, and after 2001 C&I peaked at 2.24% against 0.20% for CRE. Judged on losses alone, C&I would need a screen of its own. That said, charge-offs may understate CRE stress, because modifications and extensions can delay a stressed loan's move to nonperforming.
The screen exists because CRE losses are correlated and CRE books are large. CRE values can be materially affected by interest rates: rates move capitalization rates, and capitalization rates move the collateral value behind every loan in the book at the same time. The loans themselves mature and reprice on their own schedules, but many carry a balloon that forces a refinancing into whatever rate environment exists at maturity. A typical C&I book spans unrelated industries and repays out of operating cash flow. Its borrowers can also raise their own prices as costs rise, across a broad base of customers, while CRE rent escalations are often capped, reset on a lag and spread across far fewer tenants. Rates are moving again, with the 10-year Treasury closing at 5.31% on October 5th and 4.94% on October 30th.
The second reason is size. In the June 30th, 2026 call report data for the 4,313 institutions in the FDIC's financial data, on a broad measure that includes owner-occupied property, which the guidance excludes, median CRE runs at 309% of total risk-based capital for banks between $1 billion and $10 billion, against 66% for C&I. Above $100 billion the relationship inverts, 52% CRE against 113% C&I. Of the 1,241 institutions at or above 300% on this broader measure, all but one hold less than $100 billion in assets, and the exception crossed that line through a merger. As an illustration, a 2.5% annual loss rate against a book at 300% of capital consumes roughly 7.5 points of capital in a year. The same rate against a 66% C&I book consumes about 1.7.
In our view, banks under $100 billion did not set out to concentrate in CRE; other lending moved away from them. Residential mortgage moved to the secondary market. Larger C&I loans moved to national banks and the syndicated loan market. What stayed was the lending where local appraisal knowledge and long sponsor relationships still give a regional bank an advantage. Each shift made sense at the time, but the result is that the banks least able to diversify hold the most correlated loans, because C&I, the loan type that would diversify them, was the first to leave.
The 300% figure is a screening criterion, not a limit, and its second half, 50% CRE growth over the prior 36 months, is usually dropped in secondary commentary. On the guidance's own refined measure, which excludes owner-occupied property, the median institution sat at 132% of capital at June 30th against 177% in 2008, and 414 institutions, or 9.6%, were at or above 300%.
Caird View: We see diversified, floating-rate C&I exposure, designed to fit within the bank's C&I lending mandate, as one offsetting asset for a concentrated regional balance sheet. Senior secured syndicated loans, new issue or seasoned and approved by the bank by name, are one way to hold it without first rebuilding the origination franchise that once produced it. Diversification does not eliminate the risk of loss.
Investing in broadly syndicated loans involves credit, liquidity and interest-rate risk. Loans may trade below par and may be difficult to value or sell in stressed markets. Capital treatment reflects Caird's reading of the rules as of the date noted, is not regulatory advice, and should be confirmed with the bank's own advisers and primary regulator. The 2006 guidance is cited as of October 2026 and is subject to change; no regulator has endorsed or reviewed this material. Sources: Caird calculations from the FDIC public financial data API, report dates December 31st, 2025 and June 30th, 2026, all call report filers in the FDIC financial data, CRE as construction, land development, multifamily and nonfarm nonresidential loans including owner-occupied, with the refined measure excluding owner-occupied, total risk-based capital as tier 1 plus tier 2, medians of per-institution ratios; Federal Reserve, Charge-Off and Delinquency Rates on Loans and Leases at Commercial Banks, 1Q85 to 2Q26; Federal Reserve, An Analysis of the Impact of the Commercial Real Estate Concentration Guidance, 2013 (2008 refined median); Interagency Guidance on Concentrations in Commercial Real Estate Lending, December 2006; Federal Reserve H.15, October 30th, 2026.
BY THE NUMBERS
MARKET SIGNALS
SPREADS SPLIT
Syndicated Loans
Lower-rated loans are paying more; BB loans are not
In the second quarter B-minus loan spreads widened 55 bps while higher-rated loans barely moved, and the third quarter kept that split. New BB loans cleared at an average of SOFR plus 206 bps in September, against 225 in June. Single-B loans went the other way, to 337 from 327, and B3 and B-minus loans rose to 375 from a seven-month low of 344 in August. Investors filling CLO warehouses kept bidding for BB loans and asked more of the weakest names. Activity slowed over the quarter: third quarter institutional issuance of about $195 billion was the year's lowest, though repricings picked up again in September.
Sources: Covenant Review (Fitch Solutions), US Trendlines, October 2026, and CR Trendlines, July 22nd, 2026 (average new-issue clearing spreads by rating, June and September); Fidelity, Q2 2026 loan market review; Sikich, Q3 2026 credit market update (third quarter issuance).
Syndicated loans carry credit, liquidity and interest-rate risk, may trade below par and may be difficult to value or sell in stressed markets. Wider spreads can mean higher risk, spreads can widen further, and any spread pickup is not guaranteed.
HIGH-GRADE WIDENING
Securities
Parts of the high-grade market have widened on supply
Spreads across high-grade securitized and government-guaranteed securities have stopped moving together. Several short-duration sectors have widened in recent weeks; in our view, much of it reflects heavy new-issue supply rather than a change in credit, while others have not moved at all. Many bank securities portfolios still carry mark-to-market losses, likely larger after the third quarter rate move. For new money, parts of the high-grade securities market now offer wider spreads than they did before the supply came.
Securitized and government-guaranteed securities carry credit, structural, prepayment, extension, liquidity and interest-rate risk, may decline in value, and are not suitable for all investors. Wider spreads can mean higher risk, and spreads can widen further. Caird may hold the securities discussed and receives fees that create conflicts of interest.
WATCH
AI Infrastructure Debt
A business model that needs uninterrupted access to capital
CoreWeave's five-year credit default swaps rose above 1,100 bps on October 15th, past the 1,000 bps level S&P Global Market Intelligence treats as a sign of stress, and its 9.75% notes due 2031 yielded 15.6% to maturity on November 3rd. On October 14th, AI-related high yield spreads widened 25 bps in a single day, to 360 bps by Goldman Sachs' measure, against 2 bps for the rest of high yield. Oracle's CDS reached a record 288 bps on October 15th. Most of these borrowers depend on continued access to new debt. CoreWeave carries about $50 billion of debt and lease obligations, about $7.5 billion of it classified as current at June 30th, and data center ABS issuance went from $2.4 billion in 2020 to $15.5 billion last year, per Bloomberg. Banks reach this exposure through construction loans, warehouse lines and fund finance as well as direct lending.
WATCH
Long-Dated Oil
The back of the curve is moving
Front-month oil has carried a war premium since the conflict with Iran began in February. What changed this fall is the back of the curve. December 2027 Brent futures set new contract highs at the end of September and stood at $84.88 on November 3rd, up 21% from $70.09 at June 30th, as attacks on shipping around the Strait of Hormuz made October the war's worst month and daily vessel transits fell to single digits vs about 125 before the conflict. A front-month spike is a shock borrowers can wait out. A higher price for delivery a year from now is a cost they have to budget, and it reaches transportation, chemicals and consumer-facing borrowers through margins.
Sources: Guggenheim Investments, 3Q 2026 sector views and Bank of America data via National Mortgage News (securitized supply); CNBC, October 14th and 15th, 2026 (CoreWeave); Goldman Sachs note of October 16th, 2026, via Yahoo Finance (AI high yield spread, October 13th to 14th); S&P Global Market Intelligence and LSEG via Securitas (Oracle CDS); CoreWeave Q2 2026 disclosure; Bloomberg, November 3rd, 2026 (CoreWeave 9.75% 2031 notes, yield to maturity); Bloomberg (data center ABS issuance). Long-dated oil: Deutsche Bank via FXStreet, September 29th and 30th, 2026; Bloomberg, ICE Brent December 2027 contract (COZ7 Comdty), June 30th and November 3rd, 2026; International Maritime Organization via USNI News, October 22nd, 2026; CNBC, October 9th, 2026 (vessel transits).
FOUR THINGS WE ARE TALKING ABOUT
01 CLO WAREHOUSES: DEALERS ARE LEANING INTO PRIVATE CREDIT COLLATERAL
The Fed's June dealer survey asked about CLO warehouse financing. About two-thirds of the 20 dealers are active in syndicated loan CLO warehouses, where terms and demand were little changed. About half are active in private credit CLO warehouses; of those, roughly two-thirds saw higher demand and a net one-third increased what they provide, even as a net one-fifth tightened terms over collateral quality and valuation. Dealers are extending more against the collateral they say is hardest to value. The survey is a directional read from 20 dealers, not volumes or spreads.
02 NDFI LENDING: THE LINE ITEM EVERY BANK NOW REPORTS
Every bank now reports its loans to nondepository financial institutions as a separate line on its call report, and banks over $10 billion also break that total out by five types of lender. A bank financing a fund lends against loans it did not underwrite. Depending on the structure, collateral reporting and loan-level data can give it good visibility into the underlying borrowers, but that view is generally less granular than the one its own C&I book gives it. The chart below shows how fast that line has grown.
03 THIRD QUARTER: C&I GROWTH IS RUNNING AHEAD AT THE LARGEST BANKS
On the Fed's H.8 data, C&I loans at the 25 largest domestic banks grew 9.4% over the year to September, and at the U.S. offices of foreign banks 18.0%. At all other domestic banks it was 5.1%. Third quarter earnings releases show how uneven the quarter was: of 39 banks we reviewed, 15 reported lower C&I balances at September 30th than at June 30th, the median bank grew 1.0% on the quarter, and 10 of the 22 with less than $10 billion in assets shrank.
04 FUNDING: BANKS ARE BORROWING AGAIN
Federal Home Loan Bank advances reached $810.7 billion at June 30th, up $134.0 billion, or 20%, in the first half of the year. Borrowings across commercial banks on the Fed's H.8 report stood at $2.41 trillion in the week ended October 21st, up 12% on the year. The spare cash that could absorb a funding squeeze is also mostly gone, with the Fed's overnight reverse repo facility at $0.4 billion on November 3rd. Short-term advances reprice with each rate increase, so the Fed's September increase reaches these banks' funding costs directly.
Sources: Federal Reserve, Senior Credit Officer Opinion Survey on Dealer Financing Terms, June 2026 (fielded May 12th to 26th, 20 institutions); FDIC Quarterly Banking Profile, Q2 2026; FFIEC call report instructions, Schedule RC-C; Federal Reserve H.8, October 23rd, 2026, seasonally adjusted, September 2026 against September 2025 (large banks are the 25 largest domestically chartered; small are all other domestically chartered); Caird review of 39 bank Q3 2026 earnings releases filed with the SEC October 1st to 27th, 2026, period-end C&I balances as each bank defines them (banks not named; reconfirm against each bank's filings before reliance); FHLBanks Office of Finance, Combined Operating Highlights, Q2 2026 (preliminary, unaudited); Federal Reserve H.8, week ended October 21st, 2026, and overnight reverse repo data, November 3rd, 2026, via FRED.
FROM OUR CONVERSATIONS
What We Are Hearing From Banks
Questions paraphrased from recent conversations with bank executives.
Rates are going up again. Does our securities book get worse before it gets better?
If rates hold near current levels, likely yes. The 10-year ended the third quarter at 5.29%, 85 bps above June 30th, so third quarter marks are likely to be weaker than June's, though the 10-year has eased since. The book recovers as bonds pull to par, which runs to their maturity. What a bank can change is what new purchases go into. For reinvestment we have favored floating-rate securities such as CLO AAA tranches; that limits added duration but does not address losses already held, and it gives up income if rates fall.
How do we add commercial exposure without hiring a team to originate it?
Rebuilding a C&I origination franchise means lenders, compensation, ramp time and fixed cost carried well before the first loan funds. The alternatives are participations from a correspondent, a seat alongside a lead bank, or syndicated loans bought at issue or in the secondary market. Each is designed to fit within a bank's C&I lending mandate; classification and capital treatment are each bank's determination. They differ in how much control the bank keeps over selection, how fast a position can be added or reduced, and how much diligence each credit gets before it lands on the books.
Our loans to deposits ratio is in a good spot now, but that can change, and we have seasonal loan demand.
That is the case for setting a portfolio up before it is needed. The slow part of holding syndicated loans is the setup: board approval, credit policy, concentration limits and onboarding, which can take months. Done while liquidity is comfortable, the framework sits ready and undeployed. When deposits run ahead of local loan demand, positions can typically be committed within days, subject to availability and loan-market settlement timelines, which run longer than for bonds. When seasonal or core demand returns, they can be reduced, because the loans trade in a secondary market, with the caveat that secondary liquidity can thin in stressed markets.
Sources: Federal Reserve H.15, June 30th and September 30th, 2026. Securities and syndicated loans carry credit, liquidity and interest-rate risk, may trade below par and may be difficult to value or sell in stressed markets. See Important Disclosures.
CHART OF THE MONTH
Bank loans grew $885.5 billion over the year to June 30th. Almost half of it, $410.4 billion, went to two lines: loans to nondepository financial institutions, up 22.4%, and loans to purchase or carry securities, up 29.7%. C&I grew 6.3% and construction lending shrank.

Sources: FDIC Quarterly Banking Profile, Second Quarter 2026, Table II-A (Aggregate Condition and Income Data, All FDIC-Insured Institutions) and the quarterly narrative for loans to nondepository financial institutions and loans to purchase or carry securities. Change in balances from June 30th, 2025 to June 30th, 2026. Categories shown are not exhaustive and do not sum to the total.
MARKET STRUCTURE
Where Borrowers Go When They Have a Choice
In August Federal Reserve economists published a note comparing the two halves of middle-market corporate lending, syndicated loans and private credit. The two markets are roughly equal in size, about $1.4 trillion each as of the end of 2025, and together account for about 45% of lending to private nonfinancial companies. The comparison leaves out syndicated loans to public companies, so it sets middle market against middle market.
The syndicated borrower appears to be the stronger credit: the median syndicated borrower has $902 million in revenue and 3.2x debt to EBITDA; the median private credit borrower has $223 million and 5.0x. On average the syndicated borrower covers cash interest 3.7x, against 2.2x for private credit. Some 28% of syndicated loans are rated BB or better; the authors estimate none of the private credit book is. Median spreads are about 400 bps over SOFR for syndicated loans and about 500 bps for private credit. The weaker borrower pays roughly 100 bps more, by our arithmetic on the two medians.
The more useful finding for a bank is substitution. Firms with access to both markets move to private credit when syndicated conditions tighten and back when they ease. At the early-2023 peak about half of dual-access borrowers had moved, roughly a quarter of that year's private credit issuance. Larger firms move in both directions. Smaller firms rarely move back: about 57% of borrowers with revenue at or below $250 million have used only private credit. The authors' reading is that substitution into syndicated loans "could mitigate, but not eliminate" the effects of a private credit pullback.
For a bank lender, the syndicated market is where borrowers with a choice go when conditions allow. Private credit holds two groups: borrowers who will move back when syndicated conditions ease, and smaller borrowers who usually cannot. A bank with lines to fund vehicles is exposed to the second group, however the loans are classified on its books. Third quarter redemption requests at non-traded BDCs are one place to watch for strain in that group.
Sources: Banegas, Castelo, Degerli, Dobridge and Kennedy, FEDS Notes, Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, August 11th, 2026 (revised August 13th, 2026), data on 2025 issuance, syndicated ratings as of April 2026, private credit estimates as of March 2026; Robert A. Stanger and Co. via AltsWire, Q3 2026. Investing in broadly syndicated loans involves credit, liquidity and interest-rate risk.
THE CAIRD PERSPECTIVE
What a Syndication Desk Can Hold
Several of our conversations this fall have been with banks that run a syndication or capital markets desk. Those desks work in both directions: they arrange, sell down and participate out credit the bank originates, and they buy into deals other lenders lead. The buying side raises the harder question: how to build and hold a diversified book of syndicated term loans, at new issue and in the secondary market, without a separate credit research and trading team.
This issue's chart shows why the question matters. The largest source of loan growth in the banking system is lending to lenders, which leaves a bank exposed to borrowers it never sees. A syndicated term loan is underwritten at the borrower level, is designed to fit within a bank's C&I mandate and runs through the bank's own approval, typically with quarterly reporting, and it trades in a secondary market, though that liquidity can thin under stress. Classification and capital treatment are each bank's determination.
We work alongside the desk on the buying side. We underwrite, monitor and execute syndicated loans for bank balance sheets, both new issue and seasoned, each approved by the bank by name. We do not run customer swaps or FX. If your desk is working through the same question, email us and we will find a time to meet.
Investing in broadly syndicated loans involves credit, liquidity and interest-rate risk. Loans may trade below par and may be difficult to value or sell in stressed markets. In a broadly syndicated facility the bank is one lender among many and does not control amendment, waiver or restructuring outcomes.
CAIRD TEAM UPDATE
Where We Have Been and Where We Are Headed
This fall took us to Louisiana in September, to New York the week of October 5th, around the LSTA Annual Conference, and to Virginia, Maryland and Washington the week of October 26th, including the Virginia Bankers Association Lending and Credit Conference in Williamsburg. We were also at the LSEG LPC Large Corporate and Middle Market Loans Conference in New York on October 29th. What we heard most in those rooms: credit keeps holding up, and many examiners have not had to classify a credit this cycle; multifamily is where the stress shows, with insurance and taxes climbing and new supply capping rents; and bankers expect CECL changes that make it less onerous.
On September 30th we presented at the joint Washington Bankers Association and Oregon Bankers Association Credit, Lending and Compliance Conference, on growing C&I in a competitive market and how the channels compare. If you would like the recording, email us and we will send it.
Next up are Chicago, Kansas City and Jefferson City, Florida and California. If we will be in your market, email us and we will set a time.
From the Team: As much as we have been on the road for work this fall, the team has also found time for personal and family trips:
- Spain
- California: Los Angeles, Malibu and San Diego
- Seattle and Vancouver
- Colorado
- Texas: Wimberley
- Tennessee: Nashville
- North Carolina: Chapel Hill and elsewhere in the state
- South Carolina: Hilton Head
- Massachusetts: Cape Cod and Cape Ann
Joey's West Coast swing was part of a longer project: he has now been to every Major League ballpark but one, and Toronto is next. We believe time with family, and time to reset, is important, and we come back better for it.
The Caird Team
info@cairdinvestments.com | 469-729-0530
cairdinvestments.com | LinkedIn
IMPORTANT DISCLOSURES
Caird Investment Partners, LLC (Caird) is a Dallas-based investment adviser registered with the SEC; registration does not imply a certain level of skill or training, or any endorsement, review or approval of Caird or this newsletter by the SEC. Caird is a fiduciary subject to the Investment Advisers Act of 1940, as amended. Caird does not act as a broker-dealer, placement agent or securities distributor. For institutional use only. This newsletter is for informational purposes only and is not investment advice, a recommendation, an offer of securities, or a solicitation to buy or sell any security or loan or to enter into any advisory relationship, and it is not legal, accounting, tax, regulatory or examination advice; recipients should consult their own advisers. Any terms described are illustrative and subject to change; final terms in a separately executed written agreement prevail. Investing involves risk, including loss of principal; payments of principal and interest are not guaranteed. Syndicated loans carry credit, liquidity and interest-rate risk, may trade below par, and may be difficult to value or sell in stressed markets; secondary liquidity can be volatile and impair exit plans, and any spread pickup is conditional and not guaranteed. Structured and securitized credit carries credit, structural, prepayment, extension and liquidity risk and is not suitable for all investors. There is no assurance that any strategy will be implemented as described, that portfolio construction objectives will be achieved, or that it will produce returns; diversification does not eliminate the risk of loss, and actual results may vary materially and adversely. Past performance is not indicative of future results. Statements on call report, accounting, risk-weight or capital treatment reflect Caird's reading of rules as of the date of this newsletter, are not regulatory advice, and are each bank's own determination to confirm with its advisers and primary regulator. References to regulatory guidance reflect its status as of the date of this newsletter, are subject to change, should be confirmed with the issuing agency, and do not imply that any regulator has endorsed, approved or not objected to Caird or its services. Comparisons across loan types, markets and lending channels reflect subjective judgments in composing the underlying data; other data sets could lead to materially different conclusions. Observations drawn from groups of banks use public filings, do not name the banks, and should be reconfirmed against those filings before reliance. Information drawn from third parties is believed reliable but has not been independently verified as to accuracy or completeness. Opinions are as of the date of publication and subject to change without notice; Caird has no obligation to update this newsletter. Caird may hold or manage accounts in the instruments described. Caird receives management fees and may receive consulting compensation related to capital markets activity or fees for work related to coordinating loan transactions; these create conflicts of interest, as described in its Form ADV Part 2A. This newsletter was prepared with AI-assisted tools; its analysis and conclusions are Caird's work product, reviewed by Caird personnel. Caird Investment Partners, LLC, 3500 Maple Avenue, Suite 1580, Dallas, Texas 75219, cairdinvestments.com.